A different take on the USS Liberty


wpeBB.jpg (4544 bytes)

Captain McDonangle

Medal of Honor recipient


Liberty after attack

liberty2.jpg (23001 bytes)


The attack

2:00 PM

Three unmarked Mirages take out radios 1400 two Mirage aircraft 5 minutes (30mmcannon & 36 rockets)


Mirage star.jpg (11321 bytes)


Three jets approach. One flies 5 or 6 miles to starboard. Everyone expects it to settle into the now familiar reconnaissance pattern. As they watch a second plane dives in from port and fires rockets at the bridge. The attack on the United States has begun.

They attack again and again with rockets and 30 mm armor-piercing shells. Blood flows so thickly over the metal floor of the pilothouse that sailors trying to transverse the deck slip and fall into the blood. The dead, dying and wounded are scattered about.

                                                                                                              2:08 PM

Three unmarked Super-Mysteres attacked with napalm and dozens of rockets two 30mm gun

Mystere star.jpg (9249 bytes)

More planes come with rockets, cannon, and the dreaded napalm turning the Liberty into a floating hell. The Israelis hit everything they wanted to hit. and they had the right ordnance to do the job required:

-- heat seeking missiles to take out the tuning coils of every HF antenna

-- fragmentation bombs to take out the parabolic disks fore and aft

-- the first strafing run destroys all means of communications and all means of survival

-- the last attack is with napalm.

However, the crew was able to patch up it high-command radio-circuit antenna to send out flash messages but they discovered that all frequencies were being jammed. The jamming only stopped when the planes launched their rockets. Thus, the jamming came from the planes and could not be used while the rockets were airborne.

2:09 PM

The carrier USS Saratoga acknowledges Liberty's call for help.

Aircraft carriers.gif (9011 bytes)

Two unmarked Mirages with rockets - canons

wpeC4.jpg (5993 bytes)

Saratoga 12 Phantoms are airborn

PhantomJets.jpg (11332 bytes)
2:24 PM


The torpedo boats close in with their 20 mm and 40 mm machine guns blazing. Five torpedos launched

Torpedo boat.jpg (13833 bytes)


McNamara calls Adm Geis and orders the Phantoms recalled

 Mcnamra.jpg (2248 bytes)             PhantomJets.jpg (11332 bytes)

2:35 PM

At first the torpedo boats fired 3'' shells into the engineering spaces in hopes of blowing up the boilers.

After their attacks the three torpedo boats reduced speed and began firing machine guns at the waterline with the purpose in mind to sink her. On the Liberty it looked like the ship would sink so three life rafts were lowered into the water. One of the Israeli boats shot up two of them and the third was brought aboard as a war trophy.

There were to be no survivors!

Torpedo boat.jpg (13833 bytes)
3:05 PM

Two large Israeli troop-carrying helicopters that circled the ship and then departed without any attempt at communication.The commando's mission was to kill all survivors.

wpeBE.jpg (24106 bytes)
3:45 PM

The Sixth Fleet launches planes from the USS Saratoga. & USS America

Planes were ordered to the rescue of the Liberty on two occasions. In the second attempt the USS America also launched aircraft. Both time the Secretary of Defense MacNamara ordered the planes back. There was a challenge from the fleet when ordered back the second time. President Johnson came on the line and confirmed the order saying, Pres Johnson.jpg (3281 bytes)

"We will not embarrass an ally."

Aircraft carriers.gif (9011 bytes)


Planes return to carriers

PhantomJets.jpg (11332 bytes)
4:32 PM

The torpedo boats return and offer "assistance." It is bluntly refused.

Torpedo boat.jpg (13833 bytes)
6:35 PM

An Israeli helicopter arrives and indicates that it wants to land. Commander McGonagle gave then the finger.





Do you think these boys would have recalled the Phantoms


Nimitz.jpg (10428 bytes)

Halsey.jpg (8170 bytes)

There are always a lot of " IFs " when something like this happens.

What if the torpedoes worked and the Liberty sunk.

Would the Torpedo boats came to the sailors rescue ?

What if the Liberty didn't get a rescue message off to the Saratoga.

Would the two Super Ferelon Attack choppers have brought medical help ?

What if Halsey and Numitz were in charge ?

I imagine four of the Saratoga Phantoms would have taken out the Torpedo boats .... another six would be sent after those attack choppers so those Bilge Rats could get to see their Hebrew God ... and another twelve Phantoms would be sent to find those 4 Mirages and 3 Super Mysteres. Then the entire sixth fleet would be steaming at full speed to the Liberty and to finish the job.